When Christians say we don’t believe in anything, they’re sort of right

When I defended my thesis, one of my committee members asked me, “Why do you believe hope is a more important variable than the others?” I wrote my thesis on the genesis of self-immolation. Anyway, I gave him a long-winded answer highlighting how suicide is rarely the product of a hopeful person. In short, if an altruistic individual thinks he/she can affect change without committing suicide, they will probably not commit suicide. That’s all I’m going to write about that. If you want more you can read my thesis over on ProQuest, I’m sure.

What I should have said is, “I don’t believe [blah, blah], I accept that the evidence suggests [blah, blah].”

We atheists — many of us — are skeptics. Many of us are educated, some higher than most people. We understand how observations lead to hypotheses, and how testing hypotheses can lead to theories. But our understanding of how knowledge is formed does not mean we actually believe what we are saying.

Belief is a rather firm word. It’s difficult to change beliefs. For example, I believe my car is blue. It would be difficult for me to change that belief. I would have to paint my car, which is something I don’t want to do. So my car is blue. So what? It doesn’t mean anything.

But when it comes to important matters, we don’t have beliefs. Now it’s a given that atheists don’t believe in god, but we also don’t believe in the big bang, in evolution, in germ theory, in Kepler’s laws of planetary motion, or even in the theory of gravity. We don’t believe them because we know that someday science might prove them wrong. Rather, we accept that the evidence suggests that they are true.

When Christians, or otherwise religious people, say, “atheists don’t believe in anything,” that’s sort of true. As I mentioned before, we believe in trivial things (I believe I will get drunk if I drink a lot of beer), but we don’t believe in the big things because the evidence is not perfect. But despite it not being perfect, it’s the best we have right now.

On the god matter, on the other hand, we have no reason to accept that evidence points to a divine supernatural agency. We definitely have no reason to believe in one. So the point that religious people are trying to make is true, just not in a way that is very flattering to religious belief.

About Rayan Zehn

I'm a political scientist.
This entry was posted in Atheism and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to When Christians say we don’t believe in anything, they’re sort of right

  1. Cerberus Black says:

    Mr Zehn.
    “But our understanding of how knowledge is formed doesn’t mean we actually believe what we are saying.”

    One never has any need to believe when facts present themselves.

    When viewing that car, and others have viewed that same car as you have, as (blue) would mean that you and they are in agreement with each other on the description of an object independent of the observer, as realism has no requirement of faith.
    Belief or (faith) is just the opposite of fact.

  2. Cerberus Black says:

    Again with the moderation?

    • Rayan Zehn says:

      Do you mean: why am I moderating? If so, I’m not sure what happened. Apparently my site decided to randomly start requiring approval for all comments. I’m not sure why. To be honest I went out drinking tonight, so I’m too tipsy to deal with it now. Sorry for any inconvenience.

      • Cerberus Black says:

        The call is yours, of course. I do offer my apologies if I’ve been rather rash. But, I had no idea of this being the case.

        The last time, I thought that you were moderating my input just incase I would’ve became spiteful in my response to, som. But perhaps I was wrong…
        …and… I’m sorry.

        But for what its werth….
        I do like you and respect you, Mr Zehn.


      • Rayan Zehn says:

        Thanks mang! I always look forward to your input. But no, I’m not moderating on purpose. I’ll figure it out in the morning (but it looks like your comment came through just fine)!!

      • Cerberus Black says:

        You are most welcome, Mr Zehn. And I’m very happy that you do value my input as I very much value yours.

        I think you give a very far assessment as a skeptic, and your postings and standing offer others a keen scope on biblical texts.

        So, thank you, Mr Zehn. Thanks for allowing me to be here. And I’m very pleased to know you friend.

        Sincerely yours

  3. Pingback: When Christians say we don't believe in anything, they're sort of right | Christians Anonymous

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s